Sam Hindy

11211 expresses its deepest condolences to Sam Hindy’s family.

Landlord Forgery

Via the Times, a cautionary tale on the lengths to which some landlords will go to evict a tenant. The rule should be “trust but verify”. Before you sign anything, agree to anything, or (God forbid) go to housing court, know the rules and know where you stand.

Greenpoint?

I know there are debates about geographical boundaries in North Brooklyn, but does anyone really think that Fortunato Brothers (on Manhattan and Devoe, south of Metropolitan) is in Greenpoint?? Apparently the Post does.

District 14 School Workshops

Seems that we are on a school kick lately. We received the following regarding a kickoff meeting for a series of workshops on local schools:

The District 14 Community Education Council (CEC) and the Education Committee of Community Board #1 are planning to initiate a series of roundtable workshops to evaluate and support the needs and goals of each public elementary and middle school in District 14. This CEC meeting will set the tone for the discussions which will happen at each school, define their overall priorities and establish the procedures (which of course will be adjusted as we go along.) NYC Council Member David Yassky will participate in this planning workshop.

Please plan to attend and encourage members of your community to participate starting with this Thursday’s meeting. We need to hear your thoughts and opinions right from the start!

[…]
The first meeting is tomorrow evening:
Thursday November 15, 2007
6:30 PM
215 Heyward Street
Auditorium
This meeting is the first in a series of information and planning workshops hosted by the CEC and the Education Committee of Community Board #1. These workshops will address issues affecting individual schools as well as those affecting the entire District.

This meeting will outline the goals and priorities of the initial planning workshops. Please take a seat at the table and have your voice be heard!

For more information, please call CEC14 office @ (718) 302-7624 or
E-mail us at cec14@schools.nyc.gov

The roundtables are intended to tour the neighborhood, focusing on each of the schools one by one. Given the dismal performance of some of our local schools, and the overcrowded conditions of our better performing schools, attendance should be mandatory for all parents of school-age (or yet-to-be-school-age) children. The only way the system is going to improve is if motivated parents (from all parts of the community) get involved.

Otherwise, Williamsburg’s best schools will continue to be in the East Village.



✦✦

Evan Thies Makes it Official

Evan Thies has officially thrown his hat into the ring for David Yassky’s City Council seat in 2009 (Yassky is running for Brooklyn Borough President, as he is prevented by term limits from running for Council again). Evan, who served as Yassky’s chief of staff for five years, officially announced his candidacy today, although it was no secret that he would be running. He is the first North Brooklynite to formally announce for the 33rd, but he is not expected to be the last.

The following is an excerpt from Evan’s announcement (as more follow, we will put them up here as well):

As a believer in the power of government, I have worked to improve it from both the inside and the outside. As senior advisor to current Council Member David Yassky for nearly five years, I worked on a wide range of local issues in the 33rd District, as well as many citywide initiatives at City Hall — guiding winning coalitions on affordable housing, education, environment and government reform policy. Today I serve as the Environment Chair of Community Board 1, and as a consultant to some of New York City’s largest non-profit advocacy groups—fighting for better working conditions for blue-collar workers, clean up of the country’s largest terrestrial oil spill in Brooklyn, and against irresponsible development throughout the City.

Now I am ready to serve as a member of the New York City Council. With so many offices up for grabs in 2009, it is important we elect leaders who are going to aggressively represent the better interests of their constituents, and who have the experience and ideas to make government work for the people. I know what it takes to get the job done, and I am not afraid to fight for what I believe in.

More Schooling



P.S. 196, photo credit: malarchie

In addition to releasing letter grades for all city schools, the Department of Education has also released numerical scores1, thus allowing a direct assessment of how each school in District 14 (Greenpoint & Williamsburg, and picking up bits and pieces of Bushwick, Bed Stuy and Clinton Hill) compares to schools citywide and districtwide.

First, an update on the grades we discussed yesterday. In addition to PS 84 and JHS 126, two other District 14 schools earned a “D”, and one earned an “F”. The “F” went to PS 23 (Carter C. Woodson, Willoughby between Tompkins & Marcy2). The other “Ds” went to PS 16 (Leonard Dunkly, Wilson between Bedford and Lee) and PS 59 (William Floyd, Tompkins Houses, Throop and Tompkins3). PS 84, JHS 126 and PS 23 easily fall into the lowest 10% of schools citywide in terms of overall score4; PS 16 and PS 59 just barely break into the second decile.

Among the “A” schools we missed yesterday are:

the High School for Enterprise, Business and Technology (a mini school located within the former Eastern District High School at Bushwick and Grand)
the Urban Assembly School for the Urban Environment5 (also located in Tompkins Houses, between Myrtle & Park)
Conselyea Prep (JHS, Metropolitan and Manhattan)
PS 157 (Benjamin Franklin, Kent, between Park & Myrtle)
PS 147 (Isaac Remsen, Bushwick & McKibbin)
PS 257 (John F. Hylan, Cook between Graham & Humboldt)

Statistically, District 14 schools come out a little bit ahead versus the citywide numbers. 13 schools in the district score below the citywide median, and 16 score above. The fence sitters are PS 110 (the Monitor school), just below the 50% mark, and El Puente Academy, just above6. Five local schools fall within the top 10% of schools citywide (based on overall score): from lowest to highest, PS 132, Urban Assembly repetitive school, Conselyea Prep, Enterprise High and PS 18. All of the A schools fall within the top 20% of schools (based on overall score) citywide. PS 18 (Edward Bush, Maujer & Leonard) falls within the top 2% of schools citywide based on overall score.

Looking beyond just numbers, what is perhaps more interesting what this says (or doesn’t say) about the debate between between “progressive” and “traditional” schools. All of the top tier schools in terms of this rating (those falling in the top 10% citywide) appear to be progressive or magnet schools. But just below that, still in the top 20% citywide, are a host of more traditional schools. These include the two of three primary schools in Greenpoint (PS 34 and PS 31) and JHS 50 on the Southside.

1.Handily laid out in a spreadsheet [warning: download link].

2.Which I would call Bed Stuy.

3.Also Bed Stuy? That area between Flushing and Myrtle or DeKalb used to have an entirely different name, which escapes me at the moment.

4.Even taking these scores with a grain of salt, clearly the “progressive” parents who pilloried for trying to improve PS 84 these past few years had a point.

5 Repetitive and redundant, no? Interesting, too, that Topkins Houses is home to one of the worst and one of the best rated schools in the district.

6.The effects of grading on a curve: both schools earned a “B”, and yet they fall on either side of the median overall score.

Grades

The Department of Education released its schools report card today. By and large, the local schools fared very well, almost without exception earning strong As and Bs. The one exception is the much-maligned PS 84 (Jose de Diego), which lives up to its reputation with a D. 84 has been the subject of a nasty fight between one group of parents (generally newer residents) pushing for a “progressive” curriculum and another group parents (generally older residents) and the teachers favoring “traditional” education approaches. Based on this report card, it looks someone needs to focus on basic quality, pedagogy be damned. Unfortunately, this will probably not convince the traditionalists and teachers that change is needed, and its also going to do nothing to stem the tide of progressives to private or out of district schools (including 132).

From the Times:

A “not insignificant number” of those F schools, and even some of the 99 schools that received D’s, could be closed or have their principals removed as soon as this school year, Mr. Bloomberg said at a news conference announcing the grades. He added: “Is this a wake-up call for the people who work there? You betcha.”

Here’s the local rundown (by no means comprehensive, I’m sure I missed some):

PS 13 (Roberto Clemente, S3 & Keap) B
PS 17 (Henry Woodworth, N5 & Driggs) B

PS 18 (Edward Bush, Maujer & Leonard) A


PS 31 (Samuel Dupont, Meserole & Guernsey) A


PS 34 (Oliver Perry, Norman & Eckford) A

PS 110 (The Monitor, Driggs & Monitor) B

PS 132 (Conselyea, Manhattan & Metro) A

PS 184 (Jose de Diego, S1 & Berry) D
PS 250 (George Lindsey, Montrose & Manhattan) B


JHS 50 (John Wells, S3 & Roebling) A

JHS 126 (John Ericsson, Leonard & Bayard) D

El Puente Academy HS (S4 & Roebling) B
Automotive HS (Bedford at McCarren) “under review”

Harry van Arsdale HS (N5 & Roebling) does not appear on the list that I can see (it may show up as a series of mini schools).

Some caveats: The rankings appear to weight very heavily performance on standardized tests, which is different than academic achievement; they also give weight to schools that have shown year over year improvement. The grading was on a curve, so 60% of the schools received As or Bs (50 received Fs, and 99 received Ds).



✦✦